The only Reddit marketing platform with AI comment generation, managed accounts, and pay-per-success pricing. Compare features vs GummySearch, Redreach, CrowdReply, and F5Bot.
Everything you need for successful Reddit marketing
Generate natural, contextual Reddit comments with advanced AI. Unlimited generation included in subscription.
Find high-intent prospects actively looking for solutions. AI discovers buying opportunities 24/7.
Track brand mentions, competitor discussions, and keywords across all of Reddit in real-time.
See how ReplyAgent compares to GummySearch, Redreach, CrowdReply, and F5Bot
| Feature | ReplyAgent | GummySearch | Redreach | CrowdReply | F5Bot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AI Comment Generation | Suggestions only | ||||
| Automated Posting | |||||
| Managed Accounts | |||||
| Real-Time Monitoring | |||||
| Lead Scoring | |||||
| Success-Based Pricing | |||||
| No Account Setup Required | N/A |
Ready to see the difference?
Start with $10 free credits—no credit card required
Six key advantages that set us apart
We use our own aged, high-karma Reddit accounts (100-10,000+ karma). Your personal Reddit reputation stays 100% safe.
Only charged $3 when comments successfully post AND remain visible after 1 hour. Removed comments? Full automatic refund.
Generate unlimited AI comments with your subscription. Test quality, iterate on tone, perfect your messaging—no per-generation charges.
No account warming needed. Our pre-warmed accounts mean you can start posting quality comments within 24 hours of signup.
From discovery to posting, we handle the entire workflow. Review and approve (or enable auto-posting), then we post during peak hours.
500+ companies using ReplyAgent. Average 3.2x lower CAC vs paid ads, 47% higher close rates from Reddit leads.
Compare pricing models across Reddit marketing tools
| Tool | Pricing | Free Trial | Commitment |
|---|---|---|---|
ReplyAgent.ai | $3 per successful post | $10 free credits | $79/month for AI features |
GummySearch | $49-199/month | Shutting down Dec 2025 | Monthly only |
Redreach | $29-79/month | 7-day free trial | Monthly only |
CrowdReply | $200 minimum credits | No free trial | Credit-based |
F5Bot | Free | Always free | Monitoring only |
💡 Pro Tip: ReplyAgent's pay-per-success model means you only pay for comments that actually post and stay live. Unlike monthly subscriptions, you're never paying for features you don't use. See detailed pricing →
Choose the right Reddit marketing tool for your needs
Everything you need to know about ReplyAgent features
ReplyAgent is the only platform offering complete automation: (1) AI discovers relevant posts 24/7, (2) AI generates natural comments, (3) We post using our managed accounts, (4) You only pay $3 when comments successfully post. GummySearch (shutting down) and Redreach only monitor—you still post manually. CrowdReply posts for you but requires $200 minimum vs our $10 trial.
No! This is our core differentiator. We use our own pre-warmed Reddit accounts (100-10,000+ karma, aged 3+ months to 2 years) to post for you. Zero account warming, zero ban risk to your personal Reddit reputation. Start posting within 24 hours of signup.
You're only charged $3 when a comment successfully posts AND remains visible after 1 hour. If Reddit removes your comment, you get an automatic full refund. This is fundamentally different from monthly tools like GummySearch ($49-199/month) or Redreach ($29-79/month) where you pay regardless of results.
Yes! We offer $10 in free trial credits—enough for 3 successful posts. No credit card required to start. Test the AI quality, see comments go live on real Reddit threads, and evaluate results before deciding. Compare this to CrowdReply's $200 minimum or GummySearch's monthly commitment.
Our AI reads the entire thread context (not just the post title), understands the OP's specific situation, generates responses that answer their question first (value-first approach), then naturally mentions your product as one solution. Unlimited AI generation is included with your subscription. You review and approve every comment before posting.
You have full control! AI generates suggestions, but you can edit them extensively or write entirely new comments from scratch. Every comment requires your approval before posting (unless you enable auto-posting after training the AI). Think of AI as your writing assistant, not a replacement.
We enforce a maximum of 5 comments per day per managed account to stay within Reddit's guidelines and maintain high deliverability. This prevents spam flags while allowing consistent, sustainable growth. If you need higher volume, we can assign additional accounts to your campaigns.
You can target any public subreddit. Our AI scans your specified subreddits 24/7 for relevant discussions. We recommend starting with 5-15 subreddits where your target audience is most active, then expanding based on performance data.
Currently, our AI is optimized for English Reddit communities. We can generate comments in other languages, but the quality and natural tone work best for English. We're expanding language support based on customer demand—contact us if you need specific languages.
ReplyAgent provides direct links to all posted comments, engagement metrics (upvotes, replies), and email notifications when comments go live. For conversion tracking, we recommend using UTM parameters in your links to track Reddit traffic in Google Analytics. Many customers report 3.2x lower CAC vs paid ads and 47% higher close rates.
Still have questions?
Deep-dive comparisons and guides
⭐ We create Reddit content about your product and get it ranked in Google's top 10. Pay $69 upfront, $399 only when Reddit content ranks.
Learn More🚨 GummySearch shutting down Dec 1, 2025! Compare 5 better alternatives with full automation.
View Migration GuideRedreach provides suggestions but you post manually. See automated alternatives.
Read GuideCompare CrowdReply's $200 minimum to ReplyAgent's $10 trial and pay-per-success model.
Read GuideComplete guide to Reddit comment services that use managed accounts.
Read GuideCompare automated platforms, agencies, and freelance options for Reddit posting.
Read GuideBest Reddit keyword monitoring tools specifically for SaaS companies.
Read GuideJoin 500+ companies using ReplyAgent. Start with $10 free credits—no credit card required. Only pay $3 per successful post.