GummySearch is no longer accepting new customers or renewals. All services will cease on December 1st, 2025. If you're a current user or were considering GummySearch, you need to migrate to an alternative immediately.
GummySearch only found opportunities—you still had to post manually. These alternatives go further with AI comment generation, automated posting, and managed accounts. Compare features, pricing, and find the best fit for your needs.
Understanding GummySearch helps you choose the right alternative
💡 Key Insight: GummySearch excelled at research but stopped short of execution. The alternatives below solve this by adding AI comment generation, automated posting, or both.
From free keyword alerts to full automation with AI
Best for Full Automation
$3 per successful post
$10 free credits
GummySearch only finds posts; ReplyAgent finds AND posts automatically
⭐ Best Overall: Full automation from discovery to posting. No account setup, unlimited AI generation, pay only for success.
Much simpler than GummySearch but lacks audience insights and advanced search
Much more powerful but significantly more expensive and complex
Broader platform coverage but less Reddit-specific depth
Similar research focus but with more AI-powered insights
See which alternatives offer automation beyond just research
| Feature | GummySearch(Shutting Down) | ReplyAgent | F5Bot | Brandwatch | Mention | Subtle AI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Automated Posting | ||||||
| AI Comment Generation | ||||||
| Managed Accounts | N/A | |||||
| Keyword Monitoring | ||||||
| Audience Insights | Basic | |||||
| Real-Time Alerts | ||||||
| Pay-Per-Success | Free |
Only ReplyAgent offers complete automation
From discovery to AI comment generation to posting—all handled for you
4 simple steps to switch before the December 1st shutdown
Before December 1st, export your saved searches, keyword lists, and bookmarked posts from GummySearch.
Decide if you want research-only (F5Bot, Mention) or full automation (ReplyAgent.ai). Consider total time investment, not just subscription cost.
Configure your keywords, subreddits, and alert preferences in your new tool. Most alternatives offer similar keyword tracking.
If using automation tools like ReplyAgent, test the AI comment quality and approval workflow with trial credits before scaling up.
GummySearch shuts down December 1st. Start your migration today with ReplyAgent's free trial.
Get Started FreeEverything you need to know about GummySearch alternatives
GummySearch announced it will discontinue all operations on December 1st, 2025 and is no longer accepting new customers or renewals. The platform has not publicly disclosed the specific reasons for the shutdown, but existing users need to migrate to alternative solutions immediately.
ReplyAgent doesn't just find opportunities—it posts for you using managed accounts. GummySearch required you to manually manage Reddit accounts, build karma, navigate subreddit rules, and post comments yourself (10-15 hours/week). ReplyAgent eliminates all of this with pre-warmed managed accounts, unlimited AI comment generation, and automatic posting. You only pay $3 per successfully posted comment.
Yes! Several alternatives offer excellent audience research: Brandwatch and Mention provide enterprise-grade insights across multiple platforms. Subtle AI offers AI-powered Reddit research similar to GummySearch. For free basic research, F5Bot provides keyword alerts. ReplyAgent includes basic monitoring focused on actionable posting opportunities rather than deep analytics.
F5Bot (free) for simple keyword alerts if you have time to manually post, or ReplyAgent.ai ($3/post) if you want automation without a large upfront commitment. GummySearch's $99/month + 10-15 hours of your weekly execution time could cost $2,000+/month in total. ReplyAgent at $60/month (20 posts) saves you both money and time by handling the entire workflow.
With research tools (F5Bot, Brandwatch, Mention, Subtle AI), yes—they only alert you to opportunities; you must post manually using your own accounts. This requires 2-3 weeks of account warming and ongoing karma management. ReplyAgent is the only alternative that uses managed accounts, eliminating the need for account setup, warming, or ban risk entirely.
For research-only tools (F5Bot, Mention): 1-2 hours to set up keywords and configure alerts. For automation tools like ReplyAgent: 15-30 minutes to create your product profile and configure target subreddits, then 24 hours until your first AI-generated comments are ready for approval. The actual posting infrastructure is already in place—no account warming needed.
Yes! Many marketers combine tools: Brandwatch/Mention for deep audience insights + ReplyAgent for automated posting execution. However, if budget is limited, ReplyAgent includes keyword monitoring and post discovery, so you may not need a separate research tool. Start with one platform and add others based on specific gaps in your workflow.
ReplyAgent.ai has the most advanced AI for comment generation—unlimited generation included, analyzes entire thread context, matches subreddit tone, provides value-first responses. Subtle AI excels at AI-powered audience insights and trend detection. F5Bot, Brandwatch, and Mention use AI for monitoring and analysis but don't generate comments.
Monitoring is always safe. Automated posting is allowed if done responsibly: genuine helpful comments (not spam), respecting subreddit rules, maintaining natural posting frequency. ReplyAgent enforces 5 posts/day maximum per account, uses aged accounts with genuine karma, and generates value-first comments. Avoid tools that spam or use obvious bot behavior.
F5Bot is perfect for this—completely free, easy setup, email alerts for keyword mentions on Reddit. It's much simpler than GummySearch (no audience insights or advanced search) but ideal if alerts are all you need. Mention and Brandwatch offer alerts plus deeper analytics. ReplyAgent includes alerts but focuses on posting opportunities rather than comprehensive research.
Explore more Reddit marketing tool comparisons
Complete comparison of ReplyAgent vs all major Reddit marketing tools
View ComparisonCompare Redreach (suggestions only) to full automation platforms
Read GuideCompare CrowdReply's $200 minimum to ReplyAgent's $10 trial
Read GuideGenerate unlimited natural Reddit comments with advanced AI
Learn MoreFind high-intent prospects actively looking for your solution
Learn MoreBest keyword monitoring tools specifically for SaaS companies
Read GuideJoin 500+ companies using ReplyAgent for complete Reddit automation. Start with $10 free credits—no credit card required. Pay only $3 per successful post.